To claim this quest:
Whether you have already completed the ‘Beginner’s Luck’ quest (three fingers) or you feel ready to skip right past that one, it’s time to work your way up to four fingers. Fist likes to work his way up to this one with a variety of toys and a lot of lube. After all, the journey is part of the fun. If you can accept four fingers (or help your partner to accept four fingers) in the hole of your choosing, you can claim this quest.